The Consulting Firm for Student Athletes and their Families

You are here:

Could his 5-year-old be the future of tennis?

THIVERVAL-GRIGNON, France — It's a hot June afternoon, and Jan Silva is doing things on a tennis court few his age ever have.

At one point, he laces a one-handed, topspin cross-court shot against his hitting partner, who lunges in vain. Jan curls his arm to punctuate the winner with — what else? — a fist pump.

"He's really playing to win," beams his father, Scott Silva. "There's ice cream on the line."

Jan, or "Jani" as his parents call him, is 5.

He also is the central player in an experiment that goes well beyond what most families would risk to build their child into a sports champion. Last August, the Silvas sold their house and two cars in Rancho Cordova, Calif., near Sacramento, and moved to France with their two other children so Jan could live and train full time — with all the family's expenses paid — at the Mouratoglou Tennis Academy near Paris.

"Sold our home with everything in it," says Scott, a 38-year-old social worker who played basketball at Southern Oregon University. "We're getting Jani ready for something much bigger."

In doing so, the Silvas embarked on a potentially perilous path that families of tennis prodigies have taken with a few spectacular successes (such as Andre Agassi), some brief successes who flamed out (such as Jennifer Capriati before her comeback at age 20) and many more who never came close to being the champions their families envisioned.

Their patron, Patrick Mouratoglou, figures the estimated $140,000 a year he says he is spending on the Silvas will pay off in recognition and prestige for his academy if Jan becomes a star.

Mouratoglou, 37, also runs a management company. The Silvas, who referred to one of Mouratoglou's employees as Jan's "agent," say they have not signed any contract and have not been pressured to do so. "They just want us to see how things work out," says Jan's mother, Mari Maattanen-Silva, a former top tennis player in Finland.

Maattanen-Silva, 32, acknowledges that what she and her husband are doing is unusual, but she rejects the notion they are forcing tennis on their son. "Everyone thinks we're crazy, but when they come and actually meet us they are like, 'This kid loves it,' " says Mari, a tennis instructor who now teaches at Mouratoglou's academy. "We don't have to push him."

There's no blueprint for raising a tennis champion, but the formula often involves a kid swinging a racket before being able to read or write. Many go to big academies, though rarely as early as Jan. Parents usually are heavily involved.

Agassi's father, for example, dangled tennis balls in his crib to sharpen his eye-hand coordination. By age 6, the future eight-time Grand Slam tournament champion was doing interviews and exhibitions. Tracy Austin had her image on the cover of Tennis Week magazine before her fifth birthday; she won the U.S. Open at 16.

The Silvas' decision to uproot themselves and hitch their future to a 4-foot, 60-pound boy who likes SpongeBob SquarePants might seem bold. The examples of overbearing and fanatical parents in tennis — and numerous celebrated flameouts by young players — might make it seem reckless.

Scott, who was a counselor in the Sacramento County Welfare Department, and Mari, who taught tennis at the Gold River Racquet Club near Sacramento where the family spent much of its time, are friendly and attentive to their three children. The others are Kadyn, 11, — also a talented player training at Mouratoglou — and Jasmin, 3.

The Silvas passionately believe that Jan, and perhaps Kadyn, will be champions.

"Best-case scenario," Scott says, "is they both win Grand Slam titles. With the athleticism that Jani and Kadyn have, they can do whatever they want to do in tennis."

And the worst-case scenario?

"Jani wins a bunch of Grand Slam titles and Kadyn plays professional tennis but isn't as successful as he'd like to be, and then does whatever he wants," Scott says.

California coach Robert Lansdorp, who helped develop top players Austin, Pete Sampras and Maria Sharapova, says predicting such success for someone so young is a stretch. "I couldn't tell Maria was going to win Wimbledon when she was 14-15," Lansdorp says of Sharapova, 20, who was 17 when she won the Wimbledon title in 2004. She went on to win the 2006 U.S. Open.

Except for Austin, who landed on the cover of Sports Illustrated at 13, Lansdorp says none of his students looked like potential champions before they were teenagers. And even then, some didn't.

"You don't find that out when a kid is 5 years old," he says.

'They almost have to do it'

The Silvas say Jan's talent was evident early. Barely 1, he often demanded to see a video of a favorite player, James Blake, and soon began hitting balls for hours against a door in the Silvas' home.

The Silvas say Jan's training options at the local club where Mari taught tennis were limited. They were invited to the famed IMG/Bollettieri Tennis Academy after sending a video of Jan to academy officials, but they eventually decided the 250-student academy in Bradenton, Fla., was too big to give Jan enough attention.

Scott says IMG was wary of attracting negative publicity by working with a boy who had not entered first grade. He also says it wasn't willing to help pay for housing, education and coaching, which typically run about $50,000 a year at the academy.

Some very talented kids land scholarships or discounts at the academy — Agassi did when he went to Bollettieri as a teen — but most do not.

Mark Gorski, the IMG agent who received the video of Jan, says IMG was not prepared to give financial help to such a young prospect.

The Silvas got a break when 2006 Australian Open runner-up Marcos Baghdatis, who had trained at the Mouratoglou Academy as a teen, saw Jan play at a youth tournament in California 16 months ago. He contacted Mouratoglou, who flew the Silvas to France for a tryout and later invited them to return.

The Silvas are not wealthy; Scott says Kadyn's game (he was a top 10-and-under junior in Northern California by 8) has been hurt by a lack of money for coaching.

The Mouratoglou Academy takes care of the Silvas' every need, including housing in a small chalet just overlooking the facility's 16 courts, meals, coaching, court time and equipment. The Silvas say they would be crazy not to take the opportunity to fulfill what they say is Jan's burning desire to play tennis.

"What do you do when you have this kid that shows this unbelievable gift?" asks Scott, who says the family still rents a home in Northern California and visits regularly.

"They almost have to do it for the money part," says famed instructor Vic Braden, from whom the Silvas sought advice last year.

Jan seems to enjoy life at the academy, and doesn't appear to grasp the consequences or pressures of his being there. Each day, he trots down a small hill from the Silvas' three-bedroom, one-bath home to the academy's courts.

Jan, who has deep brown skin and shocks of blond hair, practices for an hour with Mari, attends three hours of school and returns for another two hours of tennis in the afternoon. That's followed by an hour or so of physical training such as soccer or coordination drills. At lunch in the academy's restaurant, he smiles often and pals around with older kids.

Asked about his favorite players, Jan says, "(Roger) Federer and James Blake."

Why?

"Because they are really good."

Why not Baghdatis?

"He never wins any of his tournaments." (Actually, Baghdatis has won a couple.)

During his afternoon practice, Jan — in academy-provided Nike shoes and clothes — scampers around the court against Mouratoglou. He nearly breaks down laughing when Mouratoglou makes him sprint from corner to corner. Not surprising for a child of kindergarten age, he also is prone to temper tantrums, racket tosses and sulking when he makes mistakes.

"Braden warned us that he will go through a lot of rackets," Mari says with pride and apology.

Gripping a racket nearly the length of his body, Jan's fluid strokes and timing belie his age and size. He serves overhand, approaches the net to volley and can put topspin on shots, including his natural one-handed backhand.

Braden calls Jan one of the best 5-year-old players he's seen.

"He likes competition," Mouratoglou says. "He always wants to win. He has charisma. You look at him, and you understand immediately that he's not like everyone. These are the characteristics of a future champion."

Mouratoglou admits pinning hopes on someone so young has left him open to criticism.

"I'm just saying that he's different, that he has unbelievable talent, that the parents are focused," he says. The Silvas "have a goal. I have the same goal. The kid has the same goal. We work in the same direction; it's just a matter of time."

Treating Jan 'like a pro'

The delicacies of trying to build a champion aside, Mari says she and her husband are "treating (Jan) like a pro." Jan has two coaches in the Sacramento area, another in Florida and Braden, who continues to consult with them as a mental coach.

Braden, who runs the Vic Braden Academy and is a licensed psychologist in California, says the Silvas must tread cautiously. "They have to be very careful with (Jan) because people fawn over him. I can list a lot of kids that were destined for great things and never made it."

Says Austin, now 44: "If you set your sights on No. 1 or top 10, there is not much margin for error. If you're (ranked) 300 in the world, is that a failure? The key is to know what you're getting into beforehand. Don't say you're going for No. 1. Don't just focus on that one kid. Don't make that kid feel like the breadwinner."

The Silvas say they won't be disappointed if Jan eventually decides tennis isn't for him. "I just want him to stay healthy and be a good person and hopefully become a good tennis player, because he's working so hard," Mari says.

"Jan has chosen tennis, and tennis in a huge way has chosen him," Scott writes in an e-mail after the Silvas were interviewed. "We are just doing our very best to make sure that he stays grounded."

25 comments (Add your own)

1. J.P. wrote:
Hurding your child towards "parental" goals can easily be masked into appearing as if the child likes it. This will blow up in their face. There is a long list of kids that have self destructed from being pushed like this. People, let your kids be kids. They only get once chance at it. There's plenty of time to train endless hours and work when they age.

October 10, 2007 @ 11:30 AM

2. ScottinFL wrote:
Any kid with decent skills whose lucky enough to get spoiled in great training in a particular field is pretty much always bound for glory and maybe even bound for a fantastic crash too if their parents aren't careful (see Lindsay and Britney for example). What's up with this article...is it supposed to make the average joe feel good that this kid is being put on a pedastle at age 5?

October 10, 2007 @ 11:31 AM

3. Terrance Meyer wrote:
I am more concerned about the physical pressure the child is placing on his body. Hitting top spin shots (or cuts shots) cannot be good for his elbow or shoulder at such an early age, let alone the amount of stress he is placing on his ankles and knees. The sudden stops and starts in tennis are unbelievable. My thoughts are coming from the understated Little League Baseball rules that do not allow curve balls to be thrown by pitchers under 10 or 12 years old.

October 10, 2007 @ 11:32 AM

4. James wrote:
Aside from the logistical stupidity of not knowing what the kid will be like when he's say TWELVE....this is absolutely stupid, putting this much pressure on a 5 year old. Anybody remember Marinovich?

October 10, 2007 @ 11:33 AM

5. Pearlman Jacobs wrote:
As long as the parents are unattatched to the outcome, and the child enjoys playing, I see no harm. I spent alot of time taking my son to tournaments when he was a teenager, he met a lot of nice people, learned valuable lessons about himself and life, and most importantly it kept him out of trouble.

October 10, 2007 @ 11:38 AM

6. Adolph I. Fabis wrote:
To all you naysayers -- Tiger Woods appeared on the Mike Douglas show at age 2. Need I say more?

October 10, 2007 @ 11:38 AM

7. Roger wrote:
Tiger Woods is that one kid, in a million, who made it. For every Tiger, there are a million kids who have that much pressure on them from a young age and end up not even being that interested in the sport.

October 10, 2007 @ 12:07 PM

8. Andre wrote:
What I don't understand is why would parents with a family of 3 kids relocate to France? They said for the coaching but aren't both this boys' parents tennis coaches? How great a coach would a 6 yr old need? We all know academy coaches are paid little and coach little and not that great. So after looking at Mouratoglou Academy website which says this boys' parents are now coaches there why couldn't they have given their kids a normal life and still coach their "talented" son? I am not sure what who is crazier, the parents for doing this, or Mouratoglou for allowing it? I only hope the best for the family and pray it can work out.

October 10, 2007 @ 6:50 PM

9. Pearlman Jacobs wrote:
So long as the kid is happy playing tennis, I do not see any harm in this.

October 11, 2007 @ 10:48 AM

10. darren d wrote:
This is a joke. I feel so bad for the kid. I hope he enjoy's his life of never being able to live up to the pressure his parents have put on him.

November 27, 2007 @ 5:39 PM

11. jc wrote:
darren d- you wont feel bad for him in 15 years when he is playing professionally and dominating; why? because he got a 5 year head start on his competition with all the amenities.

November 29, 2007 @ 10:43 AM

12. Frankie wrote:
I don't feel bad that his parents are making him play tennis. I feel bad that the kid looks like an oompa loompa. Check out that first picture.

November 29, 2007 @ 11:44 AM

13. Duke wrote:
Although he will be a great player for his age right now, there's no guarantee that he will be that much better than his peers when he matures. I think it's pretty crazy for his parents to be spending so much money on a risky investment.

November 29, 2007 @ 11:47 AM

14. dave g wrote:
JC, you are missing the point. He will be burnt out by the time he is 18 and he will be injured for sure. I hope the kid is happy.

November 29, 2007 @ 3:34 PM

15. Gene Dickenson wrote:
Has this kid played any tournaments yet? Has he beat anybody that is good in the 12 and unders?

November 30, 2007 @ 12:41 PM

16. steve s wrote:
Dave you don't know anything about this kid. Let him live out his dreams and see what happens. At least he is France living a good life and he will be able to say he traveled all over as a kid.

December 3, 2007 @ 5:29 PM

17. dave g wrote:
Steve,

I know I don't know him but I do know he will not make it on tour. I doubt he will even play in college.

December 3, 2007 @ 5:30 PM

18. keenan wrote:
Why should we care if a 5 year old is the future of tennis? Let's wait until he is 16 and see if he might be the future of tennis. This hype around young athletes is out of control. Everybody is the next Jordan or next Federer. Let's try and live in the moment for a day or two.

December 5, 2007 @ 11:17 AM

19. Roger wrote:
A kindergartner should definitely not have so much pressure thrust upon him at an early age. Let him at least make to middle school before deciding if he's the next Roddick or Federer.

December 11, 2007 @ 11:56 AM

20. TC3 wrote:
I've seen a story on this kid a couple of times before and I have not seen anything but a kid who enjoys tennis and a couple of parents who are trying to give their son all the support they can. Every year, parents, lots of parents, move to Florida, Texas, or Southern California so that their kid has a chance to train at one of the great tennis producing schools in the hopes that theirs will be the next great player. Whether this kid becomes a great player or not is for no one to decide now, but, his parents are doing the right thing by giving him a chance to follow a passion that he has.
As far as them being coaches themselves and not wanting to cross the line away from parents, I see absolutely nothing wrong with that. I'm sure they introduced him to the sport by being in it themselves, but wanted to remain just the parents, responsible for his personal growth and development. THAT is something I wish more parents would do, and I'm sure the USTA does too.
As a tennis coach, I see all too often, kids who start playing at 13 or 14 and never quite develop. This kid, this young black kid, is being given a chance. Why shouldn't he get it?

January 3, 2008 @ 6:13 AM

21. Sara wrote:
That's alot of money for one kid!! What about the potential of injury or the fact the kid might not want to play tennis for the rest of his life? Wow!

January 14, 2008 @ 6:22 PM

22. Jordan wrote:
This is ridic, let the kid have a life. I think sports takes looking for the next big thing too far at times.

March 14, 2008 @ 12:19 PM

23. Lauren wrote:
Hopefully all that his family has sacrificed for him will pay off.

April 7, 2008 @ 12:42 PM

24. teddy wrote:
I agree that kids should be kids but at the same time, all of this training will pay off.

May 5, 2008 @ 1:59 PM

25. David wrote:
Hard work pays off, dedication and persistence hopefully will land this kid a successful career.

June 10, 2008 @ 12:53 PM

Add a New Comment

Enter the code you see below:
code
 

Comment Guidelines: No HTML is allowed. Off-topic or inappropriate comments will be edited or deleted. Thanks.